Science and Culture Today Discovering Design in Nature
Latest

John Maynard Keynes on Why the “Argument from Design” Is Not to Be Confused with Theology

Categories
Faith & Science
Intelligent Design
Share
Facebook
Twitter/X
LinkedIn
Flipboard
Print
Email

Yesterday ENV pointed out the story of Charles Darwin’s great-great-great-granddaughter, Laura Keynes, a self-described Catholic apologist who, as an agnostic, got turned off by New Atheist intolerance and decided to pursue an authentically skeptical course of thought inspired by Darwin himself. She thereby found religion.

The article where she’s profiled, in the British Catholic Herald, also mentions that she is from a sort of skeptical aristocracy, well known in England:

Although Keynes hails from Britain’s sceptical “intellectual aristocracy” — a web of families including the Galtons, Benns, Keynes and Darwins — among her family members was a 17th-century Jesuit, Fr John Keynes, who wrote “A Rational Compendious Way to convince without any Despite, all Persons Whatsoever dissenting from the True Religion.”

Presumably the Keynes family referred to there includes the economist John Maynard Keynes. Which is interesting in itself because a correspondent just sent along a nifty quote from Keynes that nicely defines the “argument from the design” and explains why it’s not to be confused with theology:

4. The discussion of final causes and of the argument from design has suffered confusion from its supposed connection with theology. But the logical problem is plain and can be determined upon formal and abstract considerations. The argument is in all cases simply this — an event has occurred and has been observed which would be very improbable � priori if we did not know that it had actually happened; on the other hand, the event is of such a character that it might have been not unreasonably predicted if we had assumed the existence of a conscious agent whose motives are of a certain kind and whose powers are sufficient.

The source is Keynes’s 1921 book, A Treatise on Probability, p. 340, which you can find free at Project Gutenberg.

David Klinghoffer

Senior Fellow and Editor, Science and Culture Today
David Klinghoffer is a Senior Fellow with Discovery Institute’s Center for Science and Culture. He is the author of seven books including Plato’s Revenge: The New Science of the Immaterial Genome and The Lord Will Gather Me In: My Journey to Jewish Orthodoxy. A former senior editor at National Review, he has contributed to the New York Times, Wall Street Journal, and other publications. He received an A.B. magna cum laude from Brown University in 1987. Born in Santa Monica, CA, he lives on Mercer Island, WA.
Benefiting from Science & Culture Today?
Support the Center for Science and Culture and ensure that we can continue to publish counter-cultural commentary and original reporting and analysis on scientific research, evolution, neuroscience, bioethics, and intelligent design.

© Discovery Institute