Science and Culture Today Discovering Design in Nature
RembrandtHarmenszvanRijn033
Image: The Good Samaritan, by Rembrandt, via Wikimedia Commons.
Latest

Lessons of the 1973 “Good Samaritan” Experiment

Categories
Neuroscience & Mind
Psychology
Share
Facebook
Twitter/X
LinkedIn
Flipboard
Print
Email

In 1973, psychologists John Darley and Daniel Batson ran one of the most memorable experiments in social psychology. They asked students at Princeton Theological Seminary to record a short talk on the parable of the Good Samaritan, the story of a traveler who stops to help a beaten stranger after a priest and a Levite pass him by. On the way to the recording, each student met a man slumped in a doorway, apparently in distress. Some students had been told they were early. Others were told they were already late.

The result has been retold for half a century. Of the students with time to spare, 63 percent stopped to help. Of those in a hurry, only 10 percent did. (A middle group, told they had just enough time, fell in between.) Some hurried past a man in need on their way to talk about the duty to help a man in need.

Suri’s Lesson

Gaurav Suri and his co-author, Jay McClelland, use the experiment to challenge a common intuition: that the world divides into kind people and selfish people. If character were the whole story, the helping rates in the two groups should have been close. Instead, a small change in circumstance made a large difference. Our actions, they argue, often owe more to our situation than to some fixed inner essence.

From there they draw a humane conclusion. Every person’s mind emerges from the same basic principles, and each of us responds to inputs we didn’t choose. So we may focus too much on supposed differences between people and too little on their circumstances. Since we are all, as they put it, “natural systems unfolding within our particular constraints,” perhaps “a little more kindness is in order.” It is a generous way to end a book, and few would argue with the conclusion.

Where Does the “Ought” Come From?

Still, the conclusion and the premise sit a little uneasily together. That we are natural systems shaped by circumstance is offered as a description. That we ought to be kind is a moral claim. Why does the first lead to the second rather than to indifference, or to managing one another the way we tune any other system?

The parable the seminarians were preparing to discuss answers that question in its own terms. The stranger on the road deserves help because of who he is, and the hearer is told to go and do likewise. Suri’s account has room for neither a neighbor’s worth nor a command. Elsewhere in the book, he grants that moral principles we live by “may or may not be objectively true.” That leaves an obvious question: what would make one true, and is “be kind” among them?

Praise, Blame and Free Will

Suri’s case for kindness also echoes another recent book. In Determined (2023), Stanford neuroscientist Robert Sapolsky argues that free will is an illusion and that we should therefore stop blaming people for what they do. Sapolsky, fittingly, endorsed The Emergent Mind.

If no one could have done otherwise, blame does seem harder to justify. But the same reasoning cuts the other way. The Samaritan, too, was a system responding to his inputs. Does he deserve any credit for stopping? Does anyone deserve credit for choosing kindness, including the reader Suri hopes to persuade? Whether his framework leaves room for any kind of freedom, and what kind, is one of the questions I most want to hear him answer.

Situation or Character?

There is one more angle, and it is where I will turn to Jay Richards first. Does the experiment refute the traditional picture of human character, or confirm something that picture already expected? The Christian tradition has never assumed that good intentions guarantee good actions. “The spirit indeed is willing,” Jesus tells his sleeping disciples, “but the flesh is weak.” On that view, a hurried seminarian walking past a stranger is not evidence that character is a myth. It is evidence that character is hard, and that virtue has to be practiced until it holds under pressure.

It is worth noting, too, what the experiment did not find. Many of the unhurried students stopped. And the subject of their talk made no measurable difference, which says something sobering about the gap between knowing the right thing and doing it.

What to Listen For

  • From “is” to “ought.” Does “we are natural systems” support kindness, or only describe us?
  • Freedom. Is there free will in Suri’s framework? If not, does praise for the Samaritan vanish along with blame?
  • Character. Is the experiment a problem for the traditional view of persons, or a confirmation of it?
  • Truth. If moral claims “may or may not be objectively true,” what would make one true?

This is the last of six previews. I hope you have enjoyed the series on this vitally important topic in the age of AI. Over the series, we have asked whether thought is just neurons talking, whether consciousness can be explained, whether anyone is home in the machine, and why there are minds at all. Gaurav Suri and Jay Richards will take up all of it in person. Join us at COSM 2026 in Scottsdale, AZ, November 18–20; our panel is Friday, November 20, at 10 am.

David Klinghoffer

Senior Fellow and Editor, Science and Culture Today
David Klinghoffer is a Senior Fellow with Discovery Institute’s Center for Science and Culture. He is the author of seven books including Plato’s Revenge: The New Science of the Immaterial Genome and The Lord Will Gather Me In: My Journey to Jewish Orthodoxy. A former senior editor at National Review, he has contributed to the New York Times, Wall Street Journal, and other publications. He received an A.B. magna cum laude from Brown University in 1987. Born in Santa Monica, CA, he lives on Mercer Island, WA.

Walter Myers III

Board of Directors, Discovery Institute
Walter is a Principal Engineering Manager leading a team of engineers, working with customers to drive their success in the Microsoft Azure Cloud. He holds a Master’s Degree in Philosophy from Biola University’s Talbot School of Theology, where he is an adjunct faculty member in the Master of Arts in Science & Religion (MASR) program teaching on Darwinian evolution from a design-centric perspective.
Benefiting from Science & Culture Today?
Support the Center for Science and Culture and ensure that we can continue to publish counter-cultural commentary and original reporting and analysis on scientific research, evolution, neuroscience, bioethics, and intelligent design.

© Discovery Institute